The extra widespread a collection is, the extra widespread and different are interpretations of the unstated points of it. As one of the vital widespread franchises in historical past, Star Wars is rife with numerous items of such conjecture, and a brand new fan idea has supplied an alternate interpretation of what triggered the Jedi’s downfall.
You’ll be able to learn the entire thing by Reddit person TheMediocreCritic right here, nevertheless it boils all the way down to the Jedi Masters having misplaced their connection to the Drive a while previous to the occasions of The Phantom Menace, explaining why they had been unable to sense a Sith Lord shifting freely amongst them, why Anakin was so tough to correctly prepare, and the way they had been so simply worn out with Order 66. They’re nonetheless in a position to entry powers that the Drive affords them, akin to telekinesis and heightened agility and reflexes, however are not in tune with its will and steerage.
The theorist highlights particular moments akin to Yoda dueling Rely Dooku or Mace Windu defeating Palpatine, and states them to be not particularly Jedi victories, however their merely getting used to make sure Anakin’s survival and convey about his future to show to the Darkish Facet and in the end result in steadiness to the Drive.
It’s an fascinating idea, however I’m not inclined to agree with it. It locations occasions outwith the Jedi’s potential to manage, which means issues would have performed out the identical no matter their actions, and so in the end absolves them of duty for the catastrophic defeat attributable to their obvious lack of foresight.
Personally, I feel it’s much more possible that the Jedi had been the reason for their very own downfall, having gone from a as soon as extremely revered order of warrior monks in tune with the non secular energy holding all life within the universe collectively, to a secretive cabal lording it over everybody else from their ivory tower temple, diminished to little greater than introspective naval-gazers so involved with holding on to their outmoded beliefs than the occasions of the galaxy round them that they’re blinded to the rising hazard festering on the coronary heart of every part they stand for.